Skip to main content

Smart Beta and Factor Funds Explained

FB THEFINBABA

A traditional index fund holds companies in proportion to their market value. Smart beta funds follow indices built on different rules: they pick and weight stocks by characteristics such as recent price strength, cheapness, financial quality or low volatility. These characteristics are called factors.

Smart beta funds have grown quickly in India, and some have posted striking returns. This article explains the main factors, how factor indices are built, why every factor goes through long periods of underperformance, the costs to watch, and how such funds can fit alongside a plain index fund.

The main factors

Momentum. Stocks that have risen most over the past several months to a year tend, on average, to keep outperforming for a while. Momentum indices hold the strongest recent performers.

Value. Stocks that look cheap on measures such as price to earnings or price to book. Value indices tilt towards them.

Quality. Companies with high profitability, low debt and stable earnings over several years.

Low volatility. Stocks whose prices have fluctuated less than others, often in steadier businesses. These indices aim for smoother returns rather than maximum returns.

Size. Smaller companies, which have historically delivered higher but more volatile returns over long periods.

Research across many markets has documented these effects over long histories, which is why index providers, including NSE, publish factor indices built on them. Some funds combine several factors in one index, aiming for steadier results than any single factor.

How factor indices are built

Each factor index starts with a parent universe, such as the largest 100 or 200 listed companies, then applies rules:

  • Score each company on the factor, such as its momentum or quality metrics.
  • Select the top-scoring stocks, often 20 to 50 of them.
  • Weight them, sometimes by factor score, sometimes by market value with caps on single stocks.
  • Rebalance periodically, replacing stocks whose scores have fallen.

The rules are published in the index methodology. Reading it tells you exactly what the fund will hold and how often it changes, which matters more than the label on the fund.

Because selection is rule-based, smart beta funds are passive: there is no fund manager choosing stocks, and costs are usually lower than for active funds, though often higher than for broad index funds.

Smart beta versus active funds. Many active fund managers also lean towards factors such as quality or momentum, whether deliberately or not. Part of what investors pay active managers for can therefore be obtained more cheaply through a factor index. Comparing an active fund's holdings and returns with a factor index can reveal how much of its result comes from such tilts rather than individual stock selection.

Factors go through long dry spells

No factor beats the market every year. Each has periods, sometimes several years long, when it lags badly.

Value can trail for years when growth stocks lead.

Momentum does well in persistent trends but can suffer sharp reversals when market leadership changes suddenly.

Low volatility tends to lag in strong rallies, because it holds steadier, less exciting companies.

Quality can lag when lower-quality, more cyclical companies rebound strongly.

Illustration. A hypothetical momentum fund rises 40 percent in a year when its holdings are the market leaders, then falls 20 percent the next year when leadership flips, while the broad index is flat over the two years. An investor who bought after the first year's headline return experiences only the fall.

The risk is that investors buy a factor fund after a strong run, then sell during its inevitable dry spell, capturing the worst of both.

Costs and practical points

Expense ratios. Usually above broad index funds but below many active funds. Compare across providers tracking the same index.

Turnover. Momentum and some other factor indices replace many holdings at each rebalance. Higher turnover means higher trading costs inside the fund, which show up as tracking difference.

Tracking. Check the fund's tracking error and tracking difference against its index, and the size of the fund. Small funds can track less precisely.

Concentration. Factor indices often hold fewer stocks than broad indices and can lean heavily towards certain sectors.

Back-tested history. Many factor indices were launched recently but come with long historical simulations. Back-tested performance is calculated after the fact and may look better than what investors will actually experience.

Crowding. As more money follows the same factor rules, the stocks they favour can become expensive, which may reduce future returns from that factor. Large inflows into a popular factor after a strong period are a warning sign rather than a confirmation.

How to use them

As a complement, not a replacement. Many investors keep a broad market index fund as the core and add a factor fund as a smaller tilt.

Choose a factor you can live with. If you would abandon a momentum fund after a 25 percent fall, a low-volatility or quality tilt may suit you better.

Diversify across factors. Factors often perform well at different times. Combining two or more, or using a multi-factor fund, can smooth the ride.

Check what you already own. If your active funds already lean towards quality or momentum, adding a fund with the same factor adds less diversification than it seems.

Commit for the long term. Factor premiums, where they exist, show up over many years. Plan to hold through at least one full cycle of underperformance.

Rebalance. Keep the factor tilt to a set share of your equity holdings, trimming after strong years and adding after weak ones.

A broad core, a deliberate tilt

An account for index funds and ETFs

Hold broad index funds alongside factor ETFs and funds, with costs and holdings visible. Free to open

Figures are hypothetical. Index methodologies and fund details change from time to time; read the index methodology and scheme documents. This is educational material, not advice, and no fund or index is recommended. We run no tips group and no signal service, we manage nobody's money, and no return is promised.

Disclosure: the account-opening link on this page is under Atul Shrivastava's Zerodha Authorised Person registration (NSE AP Reg: AP2516003481; Zerodha Broking Ltd. SEBI Reg: INZ000031633) and earns a revenue share. TheFinBaba is not a SEBI-registered Investment Adviser — this content is educational, not investment advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are smart beta funds?

Index funds that select and weight stocks using rules based on factors such as momentum, value, quality or low volatility, rather than simply by market value.

Do factor funds beat the market?

Some factors have outperformed over long histories, but every factor goes through multi-year periods of underperformance, and future results are uncertain.

Are smart beta funds active or passive?

Passive, in the sense that they follow published index rules rather than a manager's choices, though the rules themselves are an active tilt away from the broad market.

What is the risk of momentum funds?

Sharp reversals when market leadership changes, and high turnover. Investors who buy after a strong year often experience the reversal.

How should I use factor funds?

Usually as a smaller tilt alongside a broad index core, chosen to suit your temperament, possibly combining several factors, and held through full cycles.

Disclaimer: TheFinBaba provides educational content only - this is not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.

Atul Shrivastava
Written by

Atul Shrivastava

Founder & Lead Trainer, TheFinBaba

16+ years in the markets. 8+ years teaching Python algo trading.

Full profile

Found this useful? Share it:

WhatsApp Share

Disclaimer: TheFinBaba provides educational content only. Nothing in this article is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Trading in financial markets carries risk of loss — make every decision based on your own research and risk capacity.

Free Account Opening

Open a Free Demat & Trading Account in 5 Minutes

Start trading stocks, F&O, IPOs, bonds & ETFs with Zerodha — India's most trusted discount broker. Zero account-opening fee, paperless Aadhaar KYC, and the best APIs (Kite Connect) for Python algo trading.

  • Zero account-opening fee
  • ₹0 brokerage on equity delivery
  • Kite Connect API — best for Python algo traders
  • Paperless Aadhaar e-KYC in 5 minutes
Open Free Demat Account

* Zerodha is SEBI-registered. Account opening subject to KYC approval. Atul Shrivastava is an Authorised Person (AP) — Reg AP2516003481.

Trusted by 1.6 Cr+ Indian Investors

Zerodha is India's largest stock broker by active clients (NSE data, 2026).

₹0
Delivery
₹20
Intraday
5 min
Opening