Buying index put options is the classic way to protect an equity holding against a fall. The problem is cost: protection bought repeatedly over a year can take a noticeable bite out of returns.
A put spread hedge reduces that cost by selling a further out-of-the-money put against the one you buy. The trade-off is that protection stops below the lower strike. This article works through an example comparing a plain put with a put spread, explains when the trade-off makes sense, and covers practical points for hedging holdings with index options.
The structure
A put spread hedge is a bear put spread used as insurance:
Buy a put at or near the current index level, which provides the protection.
Sell a put at a lower strike, which reduces the cost.
Between the two strikes, the hedge gains as the index falls, offsetting losses in your holdings. Below the lower strike, the hedge's value stops growing, and further falls are no longer covered.
In effect, you insure the first part of a decline and keep the risk of a severe crash beyond that. Knowing exactly where that gap begins is the most important part of choosing the strikes.
A worked comparison
Illustrative figures. An investor holds equity worth ₹12 lakh that moves broadly with the Nifty. With the index at 24,000 and a hypothetical lot size of 50, one lot represents ₹12 lakh of index exposure. About a month before expiry, under ordinary volatility and without skew:
Plain put: buy the 24,000 put at about 247. Cost: 247 × 50 = ₹12,350, about 1 percent of the holding.
Put spread: buy the 24,000 put at about 247 and sell the 23,500 put at about 72. Net cost: 175 × 50 = ₹8,750, about 0.7 percent.
| Index at expiry | Holding change | Plain put payoff | Put spread payoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24,000 or higher | 0 or a gain | 0 | 0 |
| 23,500 (−2.1%) | about −₹25,000 | ₹25,000 | ₹25,000 |
| 22,800 (−5%) | about −₹60,000 | ₹60,000 | ₹25,000 |
| 21,600 (−10%) | about −₹1,20,000 | ₹1,20,000 | ₹25,000 |
Both hedges cover a modest fall fully. Beyond 23,500, the plain put keeps paying while the put spread's payoff is capped at ₹25,000. You save about ₹3,600 on the hedge, and give up protection against larger falls. That trade-off is the whole decision.
In real markets, out-of-the-money puts usually carry higher implied volatility because of skew, which makes the sold put more valuable and the spread's saving larger than this flat-volatility illustration shows.
When a put spread hedge makes sense
Protecting against an ordinary correction, not a crash. If your concern is a 3 to 6 percent pullback around an event, a spread covers the zone you care about at lower cost.
When you would add to holdings after a big fall. Some investors are comfortable owning more at much lower prices and only want to soften the first leg down.
When protection is expensive. When implied volatility is high, selling the lower put recovers more premium.
Choosing the lower strike. A wider spread protects further down but saves less. Match the lower strike to the fall you most want to cover.
If your real fear is a severe crash, a plain put, or a put spread with a much lower short strike, fits better.
A hybrid. Some investors combine both ideas: a put spread for the near-term correction they consider likely, plus a small number of far out-of-the-money puts as cheap crash insurance. The combined cost can still be lower than a full plain put, while leaving no complete gap below the spread. Whether that is worthwhile depends on current prices, which vary with volatility and skew.
Practical points for hedging holdings
Match the exposure. Your holdings may not move one-for-one with the Nifty. A rough adjustment uses the holding's beta: a holding with a beta of 1.2 needs about 20 percent more index exposure to hedge.
Whole lots. Index options come in lots, so the hedge will rarely match your holding exactly. Decide whether to over- or under-hedge.
Basis risk. A mid-cap or sector-heavy holding can fall more, or less, than the Nifty. An index hedge reduces market risk, not company-specific risk.
Time horizon and rolling. A one-month hedge protects only for a month. Rolling each month adds costs that compound over a year; protection used only around specific risks is often more economical.
Costs of insurance over time. Spending around 1 percent a month on protection would consume a large share of a typical year's return. Most long-term investors hedge selectively, if at all, for example ahead of a specific event or when they know they will need the money soon and cannot afford a deep fall. For money not needed for many years, the cost of continuous hedging usually outweighs its benefit.
Alternatives to compare
Collar: buy a put and sell a call option, which can cost little or nothing, but caps the upside of your holdings.
Reducing exposure: selling part of the holding lowers risk with no ongoing cost, though it may trigger tax and you might miss a recovery.
Asset allocation: holding enough in debt and cash to ride out falls is often the simplest long-term protection.
Doing nothing: for long-term investors with adequate cash buffers, accepting market falls is a legitimate choice; protection always has a cost.
An account with index options and payoff tools
Compare a plain put with a put spread hedge and check the cost before placing any order. Free to open
Figures, including the lot size, are illustrations; lot sizes, margins and charges are set by the exchanges, SEBI and your broker and change from time to time. This is educational material, not advice, and no position is recommended. We run no tips group and no signal service, we manage nobody's money, and no return is promised. Derivatives can lose more than the amount blocked against them.
Disclosure: the account-opening link on this page is under Atul Shrivastava's Zerodha Authorised Person registration (NSE AP Reg: AP2516003481; Zerodha Broking Ltd. SEBI Reg: INZ000031633) and earns a revenue share. TheFinBaba is not a SEBI-registered Investment Adviser — this content is educational, not investment advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a put spread hedge?
Buying a put near the current index level and selling a lower-strike put to reduce the cost, protecting a holding against a moderate fall but not beyond the lower strike.
How much cheaper is a put spread than a plain put?
It depends on strikes, time and volatility. In the illustration, the spread cost about ₹8,750 against ₹12,350 for the plain put, with protection capped at a 2 percent fall.
When should I use a put spread instead of a plain put?
When you want protection against an ordinary correction rather than a crash, and are willing to carry the risk of a larger fall.
Can Nifty options hedge my stock holdings?
They can reduce broad market risk, adjusted roughly for the holding's beta, but not company-specific or sector-specific risk.
Is it worth hedging a long-term holding every month?
Usually not. Monthly protection costs compound over a year. Many investors hedge selectively or rely on asset allocation instead.
Related Reading
- Financing upside with a sold put
- Trading volatility with a hedged straddle
- Hedging fund holdings with Nifty puts
- The plain protective put
- A collar that caps upside to pay for protection
- The bear put spread in detail
Disclaimer: TheFinBaba provides educational content only - this is not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.